Listings · Auto
Cars.com dealer reviews: how your rating works and how to keep it strong
Official site: Cars.com (opens in a new tab)
Cars.com dealer reviews sit right beside your inventory on Cars.com, so a shopper comparing two similar trucks sees your rating before they ever call. That rating blends Cars.com and DealerRater reviews from the last 24 months, with newer ones counting more. Claiming your store is the start. A steady flow of honest reviews, each one answered, is the work.
The moment a shopper reads your Cars.com dealer reviews
A shopper has it down to two used Tacomas: same year, similar miles, forty minutes apart. Both listings show the store’s star rating and newest reviews next to the photos. One store’s latest review is from this week and names the finance manager who stayed late. The other’s newest is from last spring, with no reply under it.
Even if two businesses are close in results, the one with the stronger reputation usually gets the call. Fair?
Cars.com puts ratings and reviews alongside inventory, so they’re read at the exact moment a shopper is comparing cars, and shoppers can pick the salesperson they want from the listing itself (Cars.com reputation tools).
As of November 2026.
How your Cars.com rating is calculated
Three rules decide the number a shopper sees:
- Newer reviews count more. Cars.com weights recent reviews more heavily, and a store needs at least five reviews in the prior 24 months to get a rating at all. Below that, it shows as “Not Yet Rated” (Cars.com’s rating change).
- DealerRater reviews are part of it. Reviews posted on DealerRater also appear on Cars.com in one feed, labelled with DealerRater as the source, and the overall average uses the last 24 months of both sites combined (syndication FAQ).
- Short reviews don’t get in. Both sites require at least 15 words, which they say helps cut fraud and inflated ratings (why 15 words).
The reason is ownership. Cars.com bought DealerRater in 2016 (DealerRater), and both now sit under Cars Commerce, Inc. So our DealerRater page and this one describe two halves of the same reputation.
As of November 2026. Rating rules from Cars.com’s and DealerRater’s own help pages.
Claiming your dealership page
For a store that isn’t on Cars.com’s dealer tools yet, there’s a claim form: you choose franchise or independent, confirm who you are, add photos and submit (claim your dealership). Once you’re in the Cars.com Hub, the Your Store tab holds your description, sales and service hours, up to 15 photos and a dealership video. Only the first 650 characters of your About text show on the public profile, so put the useful part first (updating dealership information).
- Search for your store on Cars.com and check the name, address, phone, hours and photos against your Google Business Profile.
- If nobody at the store has access, use the claim form, from a dealership email address if you can.
- Write the About section in the order a shopper wants it: what you sell, your service department, and how to reach a person.
- Set sales and service hours separately, and add real photos of the lot, the showroom and the service drive.
- Add your salespeople, so shoppers can choose who to work with and tag them in reviews.
As of November 2026.
Replying to Cars.com dealer reviews
Replies happen in the dealer panel, reached from the Reputation tab of the Cars.com Hub. There, marketplace subscribers can answer Cars.com, Google and Facebook reviews from one list, filtered by date, sentiment, source and whether they’ve been answered. Only admin users can post, edit or delete a reply (how to respond). A public reply you post on DealerRater also publishes on Cars.com.
Cars.com offers seven reply templates and says to edit them before sending. Do. A reply that names the salesperson, the car and the problem reads like a person wrote it.
On the Premium and Premium+ packages, Cars.com can also ask recent sales and service customers for reviews every day, using data from your dealer management system, and answer reviews automatically. Reviews that come in through those requests carry a Verified Customer badge (automated review requests).
As of November 2026.
Is Cars.com worth it for your store?
Reviews are only part of what Cars.com sells, and the listings and most tools are paid. It sells three marketplace packages, Base, Premium and Premium+, and quotes pricing after a conversation rather than on the page (Cars.com packages). Base covers listings, managed chat, shopper alerts and dealership reviews. Premium adds salesperson reviews, automated review requests and replies, and better placement in wider-radius searches. Premium+ adds first position there and promotion off Cars.com.
For a franchise store it’s usually part of the mix. For an independent lot, it depends on your inventory, your margins and how many shoppers near you compare on it. What to watch for:
- Leads you can’t trace to a sale. Cars.com sends leads to your CRM labelled by type: tracked calls, forms, financing and trade-in offers (lead sourcing). If your CRM files them all under one generic “Cars.com” source, you can’t tell which ones sell cars.
- The same shopper counted twice. Cars.com’s Shopper Alerts reuse the contact details of an earlier lead, so they can look like new leads. Count people, not alerts.
- Placement you can’t see. The top package advertises first position in AI-powered search. Ask exactly where that shows up and how it’s reported before you pay for it.
Then compare the cost per sold car from Cars.com with what your website and Google bring in. Our guide to working out cost per lead shows how.
As of November 2026.
How ClientCzar helps with Cars.com dealer reviews
We don’t sell Cars.com packages, and we won’t push you toward a bigger one. Here’s what we do:
- Start with a free search evaluation: we search for your store the way a shopper would, on Google, Cars.com and the rest, and show you what comes up.
- Claim and correct your dealership details with you, so the page matches your Google profile and every other business listing.
- Send honest review requests to every sales and service customer, by text and email, never only the happy ones.
- Watch for new reviews with review monitoring and draft a reply in your voice for each one. You approve it or edit it.
- Track the calls and forms from your website, Google and your listings to their source with call tracking, and set the leads Cars.com reports beside them.
Your dedicated rep goes through it with you each month in the ClientCzar Portal: new reviews, replies, leads, and what each source cost.
What usually goes wrong
- Nobody owns the login. The admin left two years ago, and the hours are from before Saturday service.
- Reviews come in bursts. A push at month-end, then nothing. With newer reviews weighted heavier, a steady flow from every delivery beats a spike.
- Only the happy buyers get asked. Screening customers before asking is review gating. Google forbids it, and the FTC’s 2024 rule bans review suppression.
- Service reviews left alone. Cars.com shows sales and service reviews separately. A strong sales rating next to unanswered service complaints still costs you repeat business.
Myth and fact
Myth: “Paying Cars.com raises my rating.”
Fact: Cars.com’s published rating rules are about reviews: how many in the last 24 months, how recent and how good. A package buys placement and tools that ask for reviews. It doesn’t buy stars.
Myth: “Cars.com and DealerRater are separate problems.”
Fact: DealerRater reviews count toward your Cars.com rating, and replies posted on DealerRater carry over. Handle them together, in one routine.
Terms explained
- VDP (vehicle detail page): the page for one car, where your rating and salespeople can appear.
- Syndication: DealerRater’s reviews showing on Cars.com.
- Not Yet Rated: what Cars.com shows for a store with fewer than five reviews in 24 months.
- DMS (dealer management system): the software holding your sales and service records, which automated review requests read from.
More plain definitions in our glossary.
Questions dealers ask about Cars.com dealer reviews
Why do my DealerRater reviews show on Cars.com?
Because Cars.com owns DealerRater and syndicates its reviews. For Cars.com customers, the feed starts within 24 hours of enrolling in a package and runs daily, and each review is labelled with DealerRater as its source. Your overall Cars.com average uses the last 24 months of both sites’ reviews, and public replies posted on DealerRater publish on Cars.com too.
How many reviews do I need for a rating?
At least five in the prior 24 months. Below that, Cars.com shows your store as Not Yet Rated. Past that point the rating leans toward recent reviews, so the number that matters most is how many came in lately, not how many you’ve collected over the years.
Can I get a bad review removed?
Not because it’s bad. Reviews that break the rules, like duplicates, reviews from former employees, fraud or reviews on the wrong dealer’s page, can be reported from DealerRater’s dealer panel, which judges them against its guidelines (reasons to report). Honest bad reviews stay, so a calm reply that fixes what it can is what the next shopper reads.
Is Cars.com worth it for an independent dealer?
Sometimes. It depends on your inventory, your margins and how many shoppers near you use it. Get a quote, follow every lead it sends through to a sale for a few months, and compare that cost per sold car with your website and Google. If it doesn’t pay its way, your Google reviews and a strong DealerRater profile still work for you.
Do I have to use Cars.com’s automated review requests?
No. They come with the Premium and Premium+ packages and ask recent sales and service customers from your DMS data. You can also ask in person at delivery, by text or by email. Whatever the method, ask every customer, not only the happy ones, and never offer anything for a good review.
What does Dealer of the Year take?
A full year of steady reviews on DealerRater. To be eligible, a store needs at least 25 DealerRater reviews in the calendar year, a 4.0 average, at least one review every quarter, and at least one new-car sales review in its award category. Winners are picked by a score that weighs rating, review count and response rate, so unanswered reviews cost you here too (award rules).
As of November 2026.
Related pages
Want to see where you stand? We’ll search for your services in your city the way a new customer would and show you who comes up first. It’s free. Get your free search evaluation
Contact & Operation Lines
